So we've been eating at Capitan Steve's for a few years when the seafood hankering takes hold. They're neck-and-neck with Mayflower in terms of quality, taste, price and quantity.
We always order call-ahead take out to avoid the wait in both the takeout and sitting areas. We typically place the order at least 15 minutes in advance.
The food is always hot and fresh--never cold. The portions are ample with some to spare. I always get the fried seafood. The flavor tends to be on the lackluster side and requires some doctoring (Old Bay and Ketchup) to make it good.
I typically order the jumbo shrimp and clam strips as they are my favorites.
Overall a good place to stop in if you're in the area and want seafood but not a destination per se.