I'm a regular at the Old Brooklyn Cleats which I LOVE. We This place was a roller coaster ride start to finish.
Atmosphere: divey. Not as nice as the Steelyard location. Really bad music (read Lil Wayne).
Waitress: thought she was sweet at first. But asked us if we wanted ranch, blue cheese, and celery. I said sure. Extra $2.25 charge without mentioning it. Claimed it was on the menu, manager confirmed it was not. Blue cheese tasted like chemicals.
Beer: in plastic mugs. No.
Other drinks: $3 special on long islands, good price. My glass was cracked down the side.
We ordered wings and a buffalo chicken mac and cheese (!!!) pizza.
Wings: disgusting, covered in a pool of grease. Please see photo. Soggy and I've literally had better wings from Rally's. No really. And I consider the Steelyard location as some of the best in the area.
Pizza: absolutely delicious. I have nothing but good things to say about this. Creative and delicious.
The pizza gets a five star, the rest I'd give a one star. The manager kept trying to justify everything by blaming it on corporate. Hey corporate, here's a tip: close this location, it's ruining your reputation. If this was the first Cleats I ever came to, I'd never give another location a chance. Luckily I love the one near me so you didn't entirely lose a customer. Take a tip from me and the rest of the reviews on here.