I haven't tried the Chicago pizza that everyone keeps raving about, but I did stop here on a motorcycle ride. Their small size NY-style pizza is actually plenty for two if you don't want any leftovers. I definitely enjoyed the pizza, and I'm not even sure we were charged for soda. The waitress just gave us cups and pointed us toward the Pepsi dispenser lol.
Oh, and it was tough knowing whether they were open or closed. No cars in the parking lot, and most of the people were next door. I probably wouldn't have even approached the front door had I not asked the people outside if the restaurant was open.