I came here with a gift card and left with a mountain of meat! The store was having a 50% off sale which allowed me to indulge in some private reserve ribeyes. The marbling on the steaks looked too amazing to pass up! They were also having a buy 1 get 2 free sale on selected items so I got some tenderloin tips, beef pot roast, and brisket burgers. So far I've tried the pot roast and ribeye steaks.
The potroast came preseasoned in a bag. I decided to add some Omaha Steak brand mixed vegetables ($2.99 on sale) for an easy meal. The instructions were simple and it was a quick meal to bake in the oven with no prepwork. The potroast was tender and flavorful. The vegetables were decent, but were understandably a little mushy since they were frozen.
I followed the instructions for grilling the private reserve steaks, grilling first, then finishing it in the oven. The meat was tender and juicy with good flavor.
Mannie and Jon provided excellent service. Jon even carried my mountain of meat to my car for me. What a gentleman!
Overall the meat products they have here are good, but the price (Even on sale) is too prohibitive for me to buy from them on a regular basis. The beef here is corn and grain fed, and I would personally rather pay higher prices than normal for grass fed beef instead.