Came in today for the first time based on good reviews on Yelp. Took six bagels and the chive cream cheese to go. It was about 12 noon and the place was pretty busy with people ordering bagel sandwiches to eat there.
Being that it was noon, I didn't expect a huge selection but there were plenty of the flavors I like: everything, sesame and pumpernickel along with some others I didn't pay attention to. The french toast bagels were gone. Sorry I missed those.
When I got home I toasted the everything bagel the way I like and put on the cream cheese. Absolutely delicious. There is only one thing that I would change to make this 9+ experience into a 10: I would make the bagels a little denser in texture. I miss Bruegger's Bagels which went out of business recently. To me, those were a perfect 10.
I'll be returning to Kokobelli often.