Happy hour/dinner review, NOT breakfast...
Ambiance: 3. Jukebox: check. Patio: check. Great atmosphere: .... well the first two are all that really gets you excited about this place. Tables are plan, bar is standard, nothing stands out to me after multiple visits.
Cost: 4. Just barely a four. You can find similar prices in Tremont/Ohio City if you look around, but XYZ has some good drink specials and deals.
Food Quality: 3. After seeing reviews and pictures here it looks like this may be a better breakfast/brunch spot. But several dinner visits and I'm still underwhelmed. Some better Chicken and Waffle options in town (think Southside), burger was standard and my chicken sandwich was a bit overdone the first time I visited. Only highlight was good bruschetta that I can remember. Sound beer selection.
Service: 3. They're certainly nice which is half the battle, but the help seemed discombobulated most of the time I've been of late considering how small of a place this is. The good news even Friday night I've been able to sit down usually with no issues around prime time.
When to return: Apparently breakfast or brunch from what other reviews say. Happy hour. When you're going to the theater next door. Standard bar food with a couple of premium items. Quick drink with a friend. Off night during the week.