Gotham Bagels is the spot to be on a Sunday morning. My girlfriend lives a few blocks from here and we do not miss a Gotham run on the weekend.
The bagels are dope. Excellent consistency, great size and all your classic varieties. My personal favorite is their Super Egg Everything, which is an egg bagel topped with, you guessed it, everything. If you're really about that life, check out the bialy.
The cream cheese selection is also on point, although I rarely venture away from chive because I just really like chive.
They have new special sandwiches every week that are typically adventurous and fantastic. This past weekend I had the "Los Angeles," which had spicy chorizo, cheese and salsa verde. 'Twas delish.