I've been here many times, and there's a few reasons for this: delicious food, great atmosphere, great location, and friendly staff.
The king crab legs are my favourite. Toss in a side of corn or premium sausage for a great combination. I'd recommend getting the captain's boil sauce and medium spice for the crab legs. That's the best combo i've tried it in.
The experience is one of a kind in Toronto! to that, i am sure there will be many copy cats popping up soon but always remember this place started it in Toronto. The messiness is a good test for a first date. IMO, If the girl/guy is uptight with getting a little messy, maybe it's time to reconsider a 2nd date. haha.
Jokes aside, CB offers a fun dining experience with amazing seafood. Definitely a must try it!!
I've seen the rare negative posts on Yelp and been looking through those people's profiles - some people you just can't satisfy, no matter what. Please don't come to a place that serves high quality seafood and expect food court prices.