I've been to both excellent and really dumpy places by now. I was honestly very impressed with the Barrel Room. Everybody was polite and agreeable from the start. They happily accommodated a birthday cake I brought with me - which they refrigerated and brought out right after dinner, complete with extra plates and forks. The checks were split by default for a large group, which, if you've ever been with a large group, you'll understand how easy it makes your life. The beer list is extensive, the drinks are quality, and the food instantly teleports you way down South. It was busy yet roomy on a Saturday night. The atmosphere is unique for Cleveland; the art on the walls, the architectural details such as gas lamps inside and in make for a cozy, authentic experience. I already can't wait to come back here.