After months of searching in the area and in Toronto, I found Glitter & Grit, which is where I ended up purchasing my gorgeous Elizabeth Dye wedding dress. No other shop I visited even compared in selection and comfort (the space is lovely). If you're looking for a beautiful garment that you won't find in other stores (think styles that have a more vintage flair, made by smaller designers, and not 100% poly), then definitely check out Erin's shop.
Erin was very easy to work with (responsive, patient, easy-going), and it was a pleasure meeting her!