We attended last minute on a Saturday night. What struck me as strange was how bright the atmosphere was, it was too bright to really feel comfortable. The place was also nearly empty, only a few other couples in the place.
The food was excellent, we both had the fillet and both were cooked exactly as we ordered. What I don't think I can get over the price. $120 plus tip for dinner and 3 drinks. It wasn't terrible but I was expecting less given the casual atmosphere and the neighbourhood. The staff were all very friendly and the live guitarist was a nice touch. (Segovia was a famous Spanish guitarist).
Dim the lights, get a few more people in there and make it about 15% less expensive and it would be a great place to go for an evening out.