I work in the area, so I usually order carry-out style. As a 'yankee,' I will say that the pizza is good but it's not 'amazing.' and I've definitely had better NY-style pizza down here.
I've had the eggplant parm sub lunch special and it's pretty good. the lunch special includes chips (no drink), but the two times that I've ordered, the chips have tasted stale. I thought it was a fluke the first time but I've learned my lesson the second go-round.
I have to note that the service is not that great (at least when I check out), one of the employees (who happens to be female) leaves a lot to be desired in the customer service department. I'm not looking for a smile and some sort of sparkling greeting, but I do expect a "hello."
If you're looking to grab a quick slice to satisfy a pizza craving, I'd recommend giving rosario's a try.