We went here for fish on a Friday. If you read my reviews you'll notice that theme quite a bit. It was OK, nothing special. It's one of those places that has old time quirks, and people love that.
One of these quirks is that they don't really do a waiting list. You walk in and kind of raise your hand, they tell you to have a seat and they will come get you. Except they didn't. We watched a few groups go ahead of us who came later. Finally the group at the table next to us told the greeter to seat us ahead of them, realizing we should have been next. That was annoying.
Still, the food was pretty good, including the fish fry. Also, several friends have raved about Toby's. I trust their judgement, so if we are in the area we will give it another try. The trouble is, for us it's not close.