Looks like the reviews are dependent upon your timing and personnel.
I am not a pedicure person typically. Tried one before and it was not a good experience because I don't like people touching my feet. I was with a friend and she suggested to try again. I did and it was really nice.
I got an extended pedicure and it felt great. I like the atmosphere....music, TV. The person doing my pedicure did a fantastic job with the massage, the hot wax, etc. Loved it. I recommend to all guys to try a pedicure....no you do not have to get your toenails painted. It was relaxing and I would go there again.