Apparently I had a different experience here than Jason L. But I suppose they had a few months to clean up their act.
I met up with a few friends, and S of N were having a two for one special on all menu pizzas. We got two larges, and they were fantastic. Yes, it was a tad greasy...but its New York pizza and that is how it is suppose to be. We also got the BBQ wings, which were great.
My only negative is that it took a bit long. But, with two-for-one pizza I imagine they were getting pretty slammed in the kitchen. I will be back, even with the new Native NewYorker down the street opening soon.